Abstract

This study investigates the role of Collaborative Strategies in enhancing ESL learners' motivation. Through critical discourse analysis, three key strategies emerge - group projects and cooperative learning, interactive language games and simulations, and encouraging peer feedback and assessment. These strategies align with sociocultural theory, gamification, task-based language teaching, and social learning theory. The findings reveal that these Collaborative Strategies positively influence ESL learners' motivation, fostering a deeper commitment to language learning and promoting language proficiency and communication skills. The study offers valuable insights for teachers and policymakers to optimize ESL education, creating an empowering and engaging learning environment that empowers ESL learners for a brighter future in an interconnected world.

Key Words

ESL Learning Motivation, Collaborative Strategies, Discourse Analysis, Cooperative Learning, Games-based Learning, Peer Feedback and Assessment

Introduction

English as a Second Language (ESL) learning acquisition is of immense significance in the contemporary world due to its global dominance and widespread usage. With English becoming a universal means of technology and communication, it facilitates interaction among people from diverse linguistic backgrounds, promoting intercultural understanding (Abdelrady & Akram, 2022). ESL proficiency grants access to a wealth of knowledge and academic resources, as English is the primary language for academic publications and research (Ilyosovna, 2020). Moreover, it enhances career opportunities, as many multinational companies and international organizations conduct business in English, making it a valuable skill in the global job market (Sari & Margana, 2019). For students, ESL skills open doors to pursue higher education in prestigious universities worldwide, while travellers can enjoy more immersive experiences and cultural exchange while exploring different countries (Bergey et al., 2018). Additionally, English's dominance in the digital world enables ESL learners to utilize technology effectively and participate in the global digital economy. In the realms of international diplomacy, politics, and cultural influence, English plays a central role, making ESL proficiency crucial for diplomats, policymakers, and individuals engaging in global affairs (Coleman, 2010). It also promotes social integration and inclusivity, allowing immigrants and expatriates to connect with their host communities and build relationships across cultural boundaries.

In the realm of second language acquisition, ESL learners face numerous challenges, with one of the most prominent being the development and sustenance of motivation throughout their learning journey (Akram & Abdelrady, 2023). Psychological factors affect the learning capability of ESL students (Ramzan & Javaid, 2023). Motivation is a critical factor that significantly impacts the level of enthusiasm, perseverance, and ultimate success in language learning endeavours. Recognizing this crucial link between motivation and language acquisition, researchers, educators, and policymakers have directed their focus towards exploring and implementing effective strategies to enhance ESL learners' motivation (Jiao et al., 2022). A study on students revealed that emotions affect language skills significantly (Javaid et al., 2023). The potential benefits of motivated ESL learners are extensive and encompass various aspects of personal and professional development. Proficiency in English opens up a plethora of opportunities in the global job market, as many multinational companies conduct business in English and seek employees with strong ESL skills. Additionally, English proficiency is a prerequisite for international students aspiring to pursue higher education in esteemed universities across the globe (Richards, 2017).

Moreover, English serves as the dominant language in the realm of technology and digital communication (Akram et al., 2021a). As the digital landscape continues to expand, ESL learners have a competitive advantage in leveraging technological resources and participating in the global digital economy. In the context of international diplomacy, politics, and cultural influence, English's ubiquity cannot be overlooked. From diplomatic negotiations to international conferences, English plays a central role in facilitating effective communication among nations. Consequently, diplomats, policymakers, and individuals engaging in global affairs benefit immensely from being proficient in ESL (Akram et al., 2020).

Furthermore, ESL learning acquisition fosters cultural exchange and appreciation. With English being the primary medium for popular media, entertainment, and literature, proficiency in the language allows individuals to engage more deeply with English-speaking cultures, promoting cross-cultural understanding and enriching global perspectives (Hashim et al., 2019). Beyond these practical advantages, ESL proficiency also promotes social integration and inclusivity. For immigrants and expatriates, mastering English opens doors to connecting with their host communities, fostering a sense of belonging and bridging cultural gaps.

Therefore, investigating effective strategies to enhance ESL learners' motivation has garnered significant attention from researchers, educators, and policymakers alike. In the pursuit of enhancing ESL students' motivation, teachers play a central role. Recognizing the critical link between motivation and language acquisition, educators must employ a range of positive approaches to create an optimal learning environment that fosters enthusiasm and engagement among ESL learners (Xue, 2013). Among the various strategies available, collaborative approaches have emerged as particularly powerful and effective. Collaborative strategies capitalize on the power of cooperation and interaction among ESL learners, providing them with opportunities to work together and engage in joint tasks. By fostering a sense of camaraderie and shared goals, collaborative learning environments create a positive and conducive atmosphere for language acquisition. In such settings, students can support one another, share their perspectives, and collectively tackle challenges, which can boost their confidence and sense of accomplishment (Abdullah & Wong, 2017).

Furthermore, collaborative learning encourages active participation, making language learning a dynamic and engaging process (Akram et al., 2021b). Social media usage plays a positive role in academic motivation and academic achievement (Ramzan et al., 2023). Rather than being passive recipients of information, ESL learners become active participants in their own learning journey, promoting a deeper understanding of the language and its cultural context. Moreover, collaborative learning allows for the recognition and accommodation of diverse learning styles and preferences. ESL learners come from various cultural and educational backgrounds, each with unique strengths and challenges. Collaborative strategies cater to these individual differences, ensuring that each student's needs are met, thus promoting a more inclusive and supportive learning environment (Al-Adwan et al., 2022).

Beyond its impact on language proficiency, collaborative learning fosters the development of essential soft skills, such as communication, teamwork, and problem-solving. These skills are highly valuable in both academic and professional settings, enhancing students' overall educational experience and future career prospects (O'Donnell & Hmelo-Silver, 2013). However, it is essential to recognize that effective implementation of collaborative strategies requires thoughtful planning and consideration of the specific needs of ESL learners. Teachers must strike a balance between individual and group work, provide clear learning objectives, and ensure that each student has an opportunity to actively contribute to the collaborative process. This research delves into the vital nexus between collaborative strategies and motivation among ESL learners, adopting a critical discourse analysis approach to comprehensively examine the underlying dynamics and impact of collaborative practices.

This study aims to shed light on the multifaceted aspects of collaboration within ESL learning contexts, exploring how collaborative techniques can stimulate motivation, foster peer interaction, and promote a sense of belongingness within the language learning community. Through a rigorous analysis of discourse and interactions, this research endeavours to identify the specific mechanisms and socio-linguistic factors that contribute to enhancing or hindering ESL learners' motivation. By deepening our understanding of the role of collaborative strategies in motivating ESL learners, this study aspires to offer valuable insights and practical implications for educators, curriculum designers, and educational policymakers seeking to optimize the language learning experience. Ultimately, the findings of this research may pave the way for more effective and learner-centric pedagogical approaches that elevate the motivation and proficiency levels of ESL learners in diverse educational settings. With these objectives in mind, the research seeks to address the following questions:

1. What are the most prevalent collaborative strategies, ESL teachers employ in the classroom?

2. How do students respond to different types of collaborative strategies?

Method

Participants

Six schools participated in the painstakingly planned study. Participants were carefully chosen using a purposeful sampling methodology, which is well suited for its deliberate focus on persons who are extremely educated about or acquainted with the phenomena of interest. The study's main participants were six English language instructors. These individuals were not chosen at random; rather, they were chosen intentionally because of their extensive classroom experience. 




Instrument

The investigatory portion of the study was distinguished by an experiential method, with the researcher acting as an observer within the fabric of the classroom environment. Each teacher was observed in their regular teaching environment during a single class session, which lasted roughly 45 minutes. This real-time observation provides a raw, unfiltered view of the classroom dynamics, capturing the unpredictability and truthfulness of the interactions between teachers and pupils.

The discussions throughout these sessions were painstakingly documented utilizing audio devices to assure correctness and permit in-depth analysis. This method recorded not just the feedback's substance but also the nuances of the teachers' delivery - tone, emphasis, tempo, and other aural cues that contribute to the overall effect of their communication.

Following the observations in class, the audio recordings were meticulously transcribed, transforming the rich aural data into a textual format that could be comprehensively studied. This transcription technique retained the integrity of the classroom exchanges, giving a solid foundation for the subsequent stages of analysis.




Ethical Concerns

The four teachers who participated in the study were anonymized to protect their privacy and the objectivity of the investigation. Rather than using their names, each participant was given a unique identification number: 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6. This number coding enabled unambiguous differences between participants in the analysis while keeping their individual identities private.

Data Analysis

The model of critical discourse analysis by Fairclough (1995), was used to analyze verbal feedback patterns, ESL teachers employ in the classroom.




Results 

The discourse analysis investigated the Collaborative Strategies employed by ESL teachers to enhance learners' motivation and their influence on student motivation. Through an in-depth examination of classroom interactions and teacher-student dialogues, several key strategies emerged, showcasing their positive impact on ESL learners' motivation.




Group Projects and Cooperative Learning

In the realm of ESL education, collaborative strategies such as group projects and cooperative learning have emerged as powerful tools to enhance students' motivation and engagement. ESL teachers often incorporate these activities into their classrooms, encouraging students to work together towards a common goal. The results of the discourse analysis shed light on the positive impact of these strategies on students' motivation.

For instance, during a group project on "Cultural Presentations," students were tasked with researching and presenting information about different countries and their customs. Working in teams, they collaboratively gathered information, created visual aids, and rehearsed their presentations. The sense of shared responsibility and mutual support within the groups instilled a strong sense of camaraderie among the students. As they worked together, they realized that their individual contributions were valuable to the group's success. This realization boosted their confidence in their language abilities, leading to increased motivation to excel in their language learning.

In another instance, during a cooperative learning activity called "Problem-Solving Puzzles," students were presented with language-based puzzles and challenges to solve as a team. They had to communicate effectively, share ideas, and strategize together to find solutions. The collaborative nature of the activity encouraged active participation and ensured that every student felt included and valued. As the students successfully tackled each puzzle, their sense of accomplishment and collective achievement grew. This positive experience fueled their motivation to explore more challenging language tasks and pushed them to improve their language skills.

Furthermore, in a creative writing project called "Collaborative Storytelling," students collaboratively developed imaginative stories by adding sentences and paragraphs one after another. The exercise sparked their creativity and encouraged them to think critically about sentence structure, vocabulary, and storytelling techniques. Witnessing the evolution of their stories through the collective efforts of the group gave them a sense of pride and ownership. This creative collaboration fostered a positive learning environment where students felt inspired to develop their language proficiency and contribute actively to the storytelling process.

The results of the discourse analysis demonstrated that collaborative strategies, such as group projects and cooperative learning, not only facilitate language learning but also have a profound impact on students' motivation. By promoting teamwork, mutual support, and a sense of achievement, these strategies create a dynamic and engaging learning atmosphere that encourages students to take ownership of their learning journey. As students experience the benefits of collaborative efforts and witness the positive outcomes of their language practice, their motivation to learn and excel in ESL education becomes not just a product of individual effort, but also a collective pursuit of success.




Interactive Language Games and Simulations

The discourse analysis delved into the implementation of interactive language games and simulations as Collaborative Strategies in ESL classrooms. ESL teachers strategically integrated a variety of engaging activities, such as role-plays, language-based board games, and real-life scenarios, to create dynamic and immersive learning experiences for their students.

In one instance, the teacher organized a "Job Interview Role-play" activity, where students took on the roles of interviewers and interviewees. Each student prepared and delivered responses in English, simulating real-life job interview situations. Through this interactive role-play, students not only practised their language skills but also gained valuable insights into professional communication. The activity sparked enthusiasm among the students, as they found it exciting to step into different roles and interact in English beyond the confines of a typical classroom setting. Their heightened sense of enjoyment during the role-play led to increased motivation to refine their language proficiency for future real-world applications.

Similarly, during a language-based board game session, students engaged in a game called "Vocabulary Quest." The game involved answering language-related questions and navigating through challenges on the game board. As students progressed in the game, they earned points and rewards, making the learning experience both competitive and enjoyable. The element of friendly competition within the collaborative setting stimulated active participation and encouraged students to demonstrate their language prowess. Witnessing their peers' progress and successes in the game motivated students to work harder to excel in their language skills.

Moreover, in a real-life scenario simulation, students were presented with a "Travel Adventure" activity. They were tasked with planning a virtual trip to an English-speaking country, researching travel destinations, budgeting expenses, and communicating in English to overcome various travel challenges. The simulation allowed students to immerse themselves in practical language usage, enhancing their language fluency and problem-solving skills. The sense of agency and autonomy granted to students during this activity sparked a deeper commitment to their language acquisition journey, as they realized the practical significance of language skills in real-life situations.

Overall, the analysis unveiled the positive influence of interactive language games and simulations on ESL learners' motivation. By integrating gamified elements into language learning, teachers effectively captured students' interest and enthusiasm. The engaging nature of these activities heightened students' enjoyment, making the language-learning process more enjoyable and meaningful. This sense of enjoyment, coupled with the practical relevance of language practice, resulted in a deeper commitment and enthusiasm among students to excel in their ESL education. The success of interactive language games and simulations in enhancing students' motivation underscores their effectiveness as Collaborative Strategies in the modern ESL classroom.

Peer Feedback and Assessment

The discourse analysis illuminated the substantial impact of encouraging peer feedback and assessment on ESL learners' motivation. The implementation of structured feedback sessions in the classroom allowed students to engage in constructive criticism and support one another in their language-learning endeavours.

For instance, during a writing workshop, students exchanged their essays with peers for feedback and review. They followed a feedback framework provided by the teacher, focusing on aspects such as grammar, coherence, and vocabulary usage. Through this process, students not only received valuable insights on improving their writing but also experienced the benefits of giving constructive feedback to their peers. As they actively participated in the feedback exchange, a culture of mutual learning and collaboration emerged, with students realizing that providing feedback was just as valuable as receiving it. This collaborative atmosphere not only fostered a supportive learning environment but also contributed to the development of essential communication and interpersonal skills.

In another instance, during a speaking activity called "Presentation Showcase," students delivered short speeches in front of their peers. After each presentation, the audience provided feedback on the content, delivery, and language usage. This feedback session allowed the speakers to gauge their progress and identify areas for improvement. Witnessing their peers' growth and receiving constructive feedback motivated students to work diligently to enhance their own speaking skills. They strived to implement the suggestions provided by their peers, realizing that their efforts were acknowledged and valued by their classmates. This recognition fueled their motivation to continue refining their language proficiency.

Moreover, during a group discussion on "Cultural Diversity," students actively engaged in discussing various cultural perspectives and traditions. They respectfully provided feedback and shared insights with each other, creating an enriching dialogue. As students became receptive to different viewpoints and receptive to constructive criticism, their confidence in expressing their ideas in English grew significantly. The positive and encouraging environment generated by peer feedback sessions nurtured a sense of belonging and motivation to actively participate in class discussions and activities.

The results of the analysis demonstrated that peer feedback and assessment played a vital role in enhancing ESL learners' motivation. The process of giving and receiving feedback fostered a culture of continuous improvement, where students recognized the value of collaboration and constructive criticism in their language learning journey. The desire for recognition and positive feedback from their peers acted as a powerful driving force, motivating students to strive for excellence in their language skills. As students actively engaged in providing support and encouragement to one another, they not only built a sense of community but also cultivated essential communication and interpersonal competencies. Encouraging peer feedback and assessment emerged as a valuable Collaborative Strategy that not only impacted language proficiency but also instilled a profound sense of motivation among ESL learners.

Discussion

The findings from the discourse analysis shed light on the positive impact of three Collaborative Strategies - group projects and cooperative learning, interactive language games and simulations, and encouraging peer feedback and assessment - on ESL learners' motivation. These strategies align with previous literature on second language acquisition and collaborative learning, highlighting their effectiveness in fostering motivation and language development (Ibrahim et al., 2015).

The Collaborative Strategies of group projects and cooperative learning resonate with the literature on sociocultural theory and the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) by Vygotsky. The ZPD posits that learners can achieve more with the guidance and support of more knowledgeable others (Fani & Ghaemi, 2011). In the context of ESL education, working collaboratively in groups allows students to receive support and assistance from their peers and the teacher, thus creating an environment where they can stretch their language skills and tackle challenging tasks (Saha & Singh, 2016). This sense of shared responsibility and mutual support within groups aligns with the literature on cooperative learning, which emphasizes the benefits of positive interdependence and group accountability in enhancing motivation and engagement (Nasir & Aziz, 2020).). The results of the analysis corroborate previous research, showcasing that ESL learners experience heightened motivation when engaged in collaborative group projects that capitalize on the power of cooperation and peer interaction.

To capitalize on the positive impact of Collaborative Strategies in ESL education, teachers can take several actionable steps. Firstly, they should emphasize the incorporation of collaborative group projects into the ESL curriculum. By assigning tasks that require students to work together, teachers can create a dynamic learning environment where students can stretch their language skills and tackle challenging tasks (Veramuthu & Shah, 2020). Encouraging students to collaborate in groups allows them to receive support and assistance from their peers and the teacher, aligning with the principles of sociocultural theory and Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD). Secondly, teachers should provide structured support during collaborative activities (Ali & Azamri, 2023). By acting as facilitators, teachers can guide discussions, provide language support, and ensure that students are appropriately challenged within their ZPD. This support allows students to engage in meaningful interactions and language practice, enhancing their language development. Thirdly, Teachers should design group projects that require each member's contribution for success, emphasizing the idea that students can achieve more together than individually (Khan & Mansoor, 2020). This approach fosters a sense of shared responsibility and mutual support within groups, aligning with the literature on cooperative learning and its benefits in enhancing motivation and engagement.

The second Collaborative Strategy, interactive language games and simulations, aligns with the literature on gamification and task-based language teaching (Vellayan, 2021). Gamification involves incorporating game-like elements into the learning process to increase motivation and engagement (Saleem et al., 2022). The use of language-based board games, role-plays, and real-life scenarios in ESL classrooms resonates with the principles of task-based language teaching, which emphasize learning through meaningful and communicative activities (Zhang & Hasim, 2023). According to previous research, incorporating interactive and gamified elements in language learning can enhance students' enjoyment and enthusiasm for the subject (Delizo et al., 2019). The positive influence of interactive language games and simulations on ESL learners' motivation aligns with the existing literature, showcasing how gamified language learning activities create a dynamic and enjoyable learning environment that fosters a deeper commitment to language acquisition.

To capitalize on the positive impact of interactive language games and simulations in ESL education, teachers can explore gamified language learning tools and design their own interactive activities that align with the curriculum. Incorporating real-life scenarios in these activities can make language learning more practical and relevant for students (Hernández-Prados et al., 2021). Teachers should also encourage collaboration among students during these activities, fostering a sense of teamwork and support. Offering rewards and incentives can further motivate students to actively participate and excel in gamified language learning experiences. Policymakers can support the development of gamified language learning resources and promote research on the effectiveness of these strategies. Including gamification in teacher training programs can equip educators with the necessary skills to implement interactive language games and simulations effectively (Singh et al., 2020). Integrating gamified language learning into the official curriculum guidelines can provide a systematic approach to using these strategies across ESL classrooms. Moreover, promoting equity in access to technology will ensure that all students have equal opportunities to engage in gamified language learning activities, fostering inclusivity and enhanced language learning outcomes.

The third Collaborative Strategy, encouraging peer feedback and assessment, is consistent with the literature on social learning theory and the role of feedback in promoting motivation and self-regulation (Elboshi, 2021). According to social learning theory (Bandura, 1977), learners can observe and imitate the behaviours of their peers, and this process of social modelling influences their motivation and self-efficacy beliefs. When students engage in structured feedback sessions and witness their peers' growth and progress, they perceive the benefits of constructive criticism and recognize their own potential for improvement. This aligns with research showing that peer feedback and assessment can positively impact students' motivation, self-confidence, and sense of agency in their learning process (Woodworth & Barkaoui, 2020). The results of the analysis corroborate the literature on the power of peer feedback, as students' desire for recognition and positive feedback from their peers served as a driving force in motivating them to excel in their language learning journey.

To leverage the positive impact of encouraging peer feedback and assessment in ESL education, teachers can implement regular structured peer feedback sessions where students offer constructive criticism and support to their peers. Creating a classroom culture that promotes supportive feedback and emphasizes a growth mindset can further enhance the effectiveness of peer feedback (Hong & Ganapathy, 2017). Teachers should train students in providing effective feedback and use peer feedback to help students set personalized language learning goals. Recognizing and celebrating students' progress based on peer feedback reinforces the importance of feedback in their language development journey. Policymakers can support this strategy by funding research on the effectiveness of peer feedback in ESL education, providing professional development for teachers on implementing peer feedback effectively and incorporating peer assessment methods into the official assessment practices (Zano, 2020). Encouraging collaboration among teachers and students in shaping feedback practices can create a more inclusive and student-centred approach to language learning.

By adopting these suggestions, teachers can create an empowering and supportive learning environment that enhances students' motivation and self-regulation through peer feedback. Policymakers' support through research, teacher training, and curriculum integration can further enhance the positive influence of peer feedback and assessment in ESL education. Embracing peer feedback as a valuable Collaborative Strategy can lead to more autonomous and motivated language learners, empowering them to take an active role in their language learning journey and fostering a lifelong love for language learning.

Conclusion

The findings highlight the importance of Collaborative Strategies in enhancing ESL learners' motivation. Group projects and cooperative learning foster a sense of shared responsibility and positive interdependence, while interactive language games and simulations gamify the learning process, making it enjoyable and engaging. Encouraging peer feedback and assessment nurtures a culture of constructive criticism and self-regulation, leading to increased motivation and self-efficacy. Teachers should integrate these strategies into their classrooms, creating a dynamic and supportive learning environment, while policymakers can support research, offer professional development, and integrate these strategies into the official curriculum guidelines. Embracing Collaborative Strategies empowers ESL learners, promoting their language proficiency and communication skills for a brighter future in an interconnected world.

References

• Abdelrady, A. H., & Akram, H. (2022). An Empirical Study of ClassPoint Tool Application in Enhancing EFL Students Online Learning Satisfaction. Systems, 10(5), 154.
• Abdullah, M. H., & Wong, B. E. (2017). Listening to the ethnic voice in ESL learning. The English Teacher, 12.
• Akram, H., & Abdelrady, A. H. (2023). Application of ClassPoint tool in reducing EFL learners test anxiety: an empirical evidence from Saudi Arabia. Journal of Computers in Education. 1-19.
• Akram, H., Yang, Y., Ahmad, N., & Aslam, S. (2020). Factors Contributing to Low English Language Literacy in Rural Primary Schools of Karachi, Pakistan. International Journal of English Linguistics, 10(6), 335.
• Akram, H., Yingxiu, Y., Al-Adwan, A. S., & Alkhalifah, A. (2021). Technology Integration in Higher Education During COVID-19: An Assessment of Online Teaching Competencies Through Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge Model. Frontiers in Psychology, 12.
• Akram, H., Ying-xiu, Y., Aslam, S., & Umar, M. (2021). Analysis of Synchronous and Asynchronous Approaches in Students' Online Learning Satisfaction During Covid- 19 Pandemic.
• Al-Adwan, A. S., Nofal, M., Akram, H., Albelbisi, N. A., & Al-Okaily, M. (2022). Towards a Sustainable Adoption of E- Learning Systems: The Role of Self- Directed Learning. Journal of Information Technology Education: Research, 21.
• Ali, F. D. A., & Azamri, N. M. (2023). The Students' Perceptions of Online Collaborative Learning in ESL Writing Class. Asian Journal of Research in Education and Social Sciences, 5(2), 350- 354.
• Bandura, A. (1977). Self-Efficacy: toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioral Change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215.
• Bergey, R., Movit, M., Ashley Simpson Baird, & Faria, A.-M. (2018). Serving English Language Learners in Higher Education: Unlocking the Potential. American Institutes for Research.
• Coleman, H. (2010). The English language in development. British Council, 11, 1-24
• Delizo, C., Manalese, M. J., & Buenaventura, R. (2019). Gamification in ESL learning. Ascendens Asia Singapore–Union Christian College Philippines Journal of Multidisciplinary Research Abstracts, 2(1), 12-32.
• Elboshi, A. (2021). Web-Enhanced Peer Feedback in ESL Writing Classrooms A Literature Review. English Language Teaching, 14(4), 66076.
• Fani, T., & Ghaemi, F. (2011). Implications of Vygotskys Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) in Teacher Education: ZPTD and Self-scaffolding. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 29(29), 1549–1554.
• Hashim, H., Rafiqah M. Rafiq, K., & Md. Yunus, M. (2019). Improving ESL Learners' Grammar with Gamified Learning. Arab World English Journal, 5, 41–50. h
• Hernández-Prados, M. Á., Belmonte, M. L., & Manzanares-Ruiz, J. C. (2021). How to Run Your Own Online Business: A Gamification Experience in ESL. Education Sciences, 11(11), 697.
• Hong, Y. C., & Ganapathy, M. (2017). To Investigate ESL Student Instrumental and Integrative Motivation towards English Language Learning in a Chinese School in Penang: Case Study. English Language Teaching, 10(9), 17.
• Ibrahim, N., Shak, M. S. Y., Mohd, T., Ismail, N. A., Perumal, P. D. a/p, Zaidi, A., & Yasin, S. M. A. (2015). The Importance of Implementing Collaborative Learning in the English as a Second Language (ESL) Classroom in Malaysia. Procedia Economics and Finance, 31, 346–353.
• Ilyosovna, N. A. (2020). The importance of English language. International Journal on Orange Technologies, 2(1), 22-24.
• Javaid, Z. K., Andleeb, N., & Rana, S. (2023). Psychological Perspective on Advanced Learners Foreign Language-related Emotions across the Four Skills. Voyage Journal of Educational Studies, 3(2), 191- 207.
• Jiao, S., Wang, J., Ma, X., You, Z., & Jiang, D. (2022). Motivation and Its Impact on Language Achievement: Sustainable Development of Ethnic Minority Students Second Language Learning. Sustainability, 14(13), 7898.
• Khan, A. B., & Mansoor, H. S. (2020). Integrated Collaborative Learning Approach (ICLA): Conceptual framework of pedagogical approach for the integration of language skills. Competitive Social Science Research Journal, 1(1), 14– 28.
• Athirah Mohd Nasir, N., & Abd. Aziz, A. (2020). Implementing Student-Centered Collaborative Learning when Teaching Productive Skills in An ESL Primary Classroom. International Journal of Publication and Social Studies, 5(1), 44– 54. h
• ODonnell, A. M. (2013). Introduction What is Collaborative Learning?: An Overview. 13– 28.
• Ikramullah, Ramzan, M., & Javaid, Z. K. (2023). PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS INFLUENCING PASHTO SPEAKING ESL STUDENTS' PRONUNCIATION OF ENGLISH VOWELS. Pakistan Journal of Society, Education and Language (PJSEL), 9(2), 52–63.
• Ramzan, M., Javaid, Z. K., & Fatima, M. (2023). Empowering ESL Students: Harnessing the Potential of Social Media to Enhance Academic Motivation in Higher Education. Global Digital & Print Media Review, VI(II), 224-237.
• Ramzan, M., Bibi, R., & Khunsa, N. (2023). Unravelling the Link between Social Media Usage and Academic Achievement among ESL Learners: A Quantitative Analysis. Global Educational Studies Review, VIII(II), 407-421.
• Richards, J. C. (2017). Teaching English through English: Proficiency, Pedagogy and Performance. RELC Journal, 48(1), 7–30.
• Saha, S., & Singh, S. (2016). Collaborative learning through language games in ESL classroom. Language in India, 16(10), 180-189. h
• Saleem, A. N., Noori, N. M., & Ozdamli, F. (2021). Gamification Applications in E- learning: A Literature Review. Technology, Knowledge and Learning, 27(1), 139–159.
• Sari, Y. N., & Margana, M. (2019). YouTube as a Learning Media to Improve the Students Speaking Ability in 21st Century. Journal of English Language Teaching and Linguistics, 4(2), 263.
• Singh, C. K. S. (2020). The Use of Think Pair Share of Cooperative Learning to Improve Weak Students Speaking Ability. International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation, 24(5), 4008– 4023.
• Vellayan, G. (2021). A review of studies on cooperative learning strategy to improve ESL student speaking skills. Turkish Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education (TURCOMAT), 12(3), 63-68.
• Veramuthu, P., & Md Shah, P. (2020). Effectiveness of Collaborative Writing among Secondary School Students in an ESL Classroom. Creative Education, 11(01), 54–67.
• Woodworth, J., & Barkaoui, K. (2020). Perspectives on Using Automated Writing Evaluation Systems to Provide Written Corrective Feedback in the ESL Classroom. TESL Canada Journal, 37(2), 234–247.
• Xue, M. (2015). Effects of group work on English communicative competence of Chinese international graduates in United States institutions of higher education. The Qualitative Report.
• Zano, K. (2020). For children without the language of feedback: Multilingualism in promoting peer and teacher feedback. Gender and Behaviour, 18(2), 15541- 15550.
• Zhang, S., & Hasim, Z. (2023). Gamification in EFL/ESL instruction: A systematic review of empirical research. Frontiers in Psychology, 13.